Ginza Cosmetics is one of three so-called "comeback" films set in urban environments (the other two were Dancing Girl and Meishi) released in 1951. It is the story of a few days in the life of a single bar hostess, Yukiko (Kinuyo Tanaka) with a young son. It prefigures one of his better known films, When a Woman Ascend the Stairs (1960) starring Naruse regular Hideko Takamine, which is also about the struggles of a high class bar hostess in the Ginza district. It is notable that Naruse doesn't make Yukiko's child, Haruo, a burden-he is a cheerful self-sufficient child who wanders off one day. And Yukiko is forced to leave behind a nice young man, Ishikawa, she is looking after with her younger sister Kyoko (Kyoko Kagawa). Kyoko quickly falls for the earnest young man. This kills some hope for Yukiko who vows to go on working hard to get by and bears no grudge against her sister whom she repeatedly warns about the life of a bar hostess and the importance of finding a decent man to marry to get out of the game. I think Naruse gives a sense of what Ginza was like in the early 50s with location shots and realistic details like street musicians, itinerant child storytellers, child flower hawkers, as well as neon bar signs in English and Japanese. Yukiko, is often seen with images of imprisonment, frequently being positioned in doorways and corridors, seen between partitions, framed in mirrors, or viewed through windows. There is no easy way out of the life that she has chosen and at the end of the film Yukiko is entrapped by both the bars on the bridge which hints at a paucity of liberty of movement implied by her rapid progress. In Catherine Russel's book The Cinema of Naruse Mikio, she sums up the film as thus:
This is perhaps the point where Naruse's modernity becomes recognizable as a discourse of ressentiment. Melodramatic loss and nostalgia take on symbolic weight of social allegory... Yukiko .... a survivor despite all the odds, and her trials and tribulations need to be recognized in terms of cultural critique and the realistic depiction of the life of a bar hostess as a new tendency of postwar Japan, marking Naruse's ongoing reworking of the tendency film genre of the early 1930s.
I think this film is probably one of Naruse's top 20 that I have seen with a strong performance from Tanaka and a gritty urban drama set in the bars of Ginza much like the equally excellent When a Woman Ascend the Stairs that would follow.
Recent Comments