
I originally read James Jones' epic debut novel, From Here to Eternity, based on Joan Didion's admiration for it. That novel and Terrance Malick's 1998 film version of his second novel, The Thin Red Line (1962), convinced me that I needed to read the second novel in Jones' The World War II Trilogy. To be honest, I bought into the trilogy after From Here to Eternity, since I also bought a copy of Whistle after it. But I expect I will read this year after experiencing the second volume. I don't remember Malick's film so well, but I recollect liking it. But it feels so different in tone and narrow in scope compared to Jones' novel in retrospect, but then again I am planning to re-watch it now that I read Jones' original version. Jones' version of the war, no matter how much he has fictionalized it-the Guadalcanal locations of "The Dancing Elephant" and "Boiled Shrimp" are made up-it feels true to life. Jones records the petty back biting between service men, the petty grudges, the homosexuality, the fears, the complexes, as much as the bravado, the bravery, and the competence of the servicemen who populate the novel. The novel opens as the C-Charlie Company is shipped out to Paupa New Guinea to fight the Japanese and the first set piece is a buck private roaming the ship trying to steal another serviceman's pistol-setting the tone that this is not going to a Spielberg-esque canonization of "America's Greatest Generation." Jones captures the humanity of soldiers at war-frailties as well, no romanticism here. The lack of compassion, self-control, the thievery, buggery, and savagery as they loot dead Japanese soldiers and some even collect their gold teeth. Jones follows the men through their arrival, first march, first battle, second battle, and the aftermath of those campaigns. His ensemble cast seems genuinely distinct and diverse for each individual character. He brings war to life in a very realistic and true to life fashion. Apparently, many of the episodes are based on experiences Jones had such as his captain being removed from his duty as leader after disobeying a suicide order from a general among other episodes. The novel is a classic epic and true-to life in the subtle details of interactions between men and in the greater context of war.
Recent Comments