
A couple of years ago I came across a copy of Renata Adler's A Year In The Dark: A Year in the Life of a Film Critic 1968-1969 (1969) in a cafe in Dalat, Vietnam. I liked the idea of reading about films that were released during the height of the Vietnam War and vowed to hunt down a copy once I got back home. I have read some of Pauline Kael's reviews and its interesting to see how some classic movies were received when they first were released. The Introduction explains the context of Adler replacing the dinosaur Bosley Crowthers and Adler's background in journalism. I was interested in her opinions on some films that have become classics or cult classic over the years as well as dissenting opinions on films that are well-regarded today. Near the beginning of her tenure, there is a take down of Norman Mailer's Wild 90:
"Norman Mailer's first film, Wild 90, is more or less continuous with the rest of his work. It runs on. It features Mailer. It leans quite heavily on the assumption that lack of form liberates-that time, impulse, spontaneity, a willingness to risk personal embarrassment, above all, a constant unrestricted play of energy will sooner or later yield a breakthrough into something fresh."
She is obviously not a fan of spaghetti westerns and says that the classic Sergio Leone film The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly: "...must be the most expensive, pious and repellent movie in the history of its particular genre." Planet of the Apes is dismissed: "None of it is quite up to a single episode of "Star Trek," but it is all right." The Graduate gets high praise: ""and one is in the hands of the most brilliant, if rather unstable, movie in quite some time." She gives a positive review to a little known Albert Finney directed film, Charlie Bubbles as well as Roman Polanski's Rosemary's Baby. She also has high praise for the Steve McQueen vehicle Bullitt. Adler also reviews a large number of foreign films from Czech New Wave features to films like Jean-Luc Goddard's Le Chinoise and Ingmar Bergman's Hour of the Wolf. She is also a champion of John Casavetes's art film, Faces, as well as Milos Forman's The Fireman's Ball. And there was also praise for an obscure French film L'Enfance Nue/ Naked Childhood directed by Maurice Pialat.
Here's her Top 10 for 1968 in no particular order: Charlie Bubbles, The Two Of Us directed by Claude Berri, Belle de Jour by Luis Bunuel, Faces, Les Carabiniers by Jean-Luc Goddard, The Bride Wore Black by Francious Trauffaut, The Fifth Horseman Is Fear by Zbynek Brynch, Petulia by Richard Lester, Rosemary's Baby, A Report on the Party and the Guests by Jan Nemec.
Throughout the book of reviews there are some reviews of Broadway productions (a production of Neil Simon's The Odd Couple with Walter Mathau and Jack Lemon for example) in addition to films. Not to mention she intermittently writes think pieces on films she has seen recently or genres like horror. Curiously the last three pieces in the book are on culture and film in Cuba. There is a recurring acknowledgement of the riots, strikes, and discord over the course of this book and one can learn a lot about what was going on in the world in the late 60s and as well as understand much about Adler's own tastes and opinions on art and society.
Recent Comments