The Thousand Autumns of Jacob DeZoet by master stylist David Mitchell is undoubtedly one of the best novels of 2010 and a crowning achievement. I am sure any reader who is familiar with Mitchell and books like Cloud Atlas or Black Swan Green can attest to his incredible talent stylistically and in storytelling. This novel is a product of extensive research into the 18th century Dutch trading post Dejima near Nagasaki Japan during the time of foreigner exclusion and limited contact with main land Japan. The details make the story come to life, but Mitchell has also created a compelling narrative plot with a secret evil religious sect, corrupt trading practices, forbidden love, and an international incident by a foreign power looking to expand trading in the orient. The compelling story is supported by telling details of what life was like for the Dutch trading with Japan in the late 18th century, but the characters are expertly rendered with distinct personality traits and speech patterns. The story mostly concerns Jacob DeZoet who travels east to Japan to make his fortune so that he can marry back in Holland, but things don't go according to plan. While he is in Dejima he falls in love with a Japanese midwife named Orito, and he becomes involved in several incidents and calamities that result in an extended stay on the island. Then again this is not a conventional love story either, however, without giving away too many details about the plot, I am suffice to say that it is an epic story of considerable enjoyment.
Update: I was asked by a friend to explain why I like this novel more than his earlier ones and I was inspired to write a lengthy response, which might clarify my thoughts on this novel:
I think it is a combination of stylistically creating a satisfying narrative that made me feels as though I were going back in time and entering another time period. To me the novel is epic in its scope and myriad of characters and depictions of late 18th century Dutch trading practices and life in Japan.
I think BLACK SWAN GREEN is the second most satisfying novel since he has captured the voice of an adolescent. It was an extremely enjoyable and satisfying novel, but not as impressive as THE THOUSAND AUTUMNS because Mitchell is essentially recreating his own adolescent not matter how convincingly and entertainingly-it is still a coming of age novel. It is has been done before, and I will say he does this genre well, but it isn’t the same accomplishment of recreating life from more than 200 years ago among the Dutch and Japanese not English. (I included it in my list of my favorite books from the 00s on my blog). Here’s the link to my review from 2006 and I basically still agree:
http://patrickmccoy.typepad.com/lost_in_translation/2006/10/black_swan_gree.html
My problem with CLOUD ATLAS is mainly due to the Sci-Fi story embedded in the novel, which I found juvenile and boring. I Believe I skimmed through those parts, but found the other sections absolutely fascinating and a tribute to his ability to mimic nearly any style of writing convincingly, but I felt that he still hadn’t truly found his own writer-ly voice. This is from my blog post in 2005-follwed by the link:
I particularly liked “The Pacific Journal of Adam Ewing”-which probably owes something to Melville, and “Letter From Zedelghem”-which reminded me of the Dangerous Liaisons although it took place much later in time. There were merits to the “The First Luis Rey Mystery” and “The Ghastly Ordeal of Timothy Cavendish,” as well. But I was turned off by the lengthy foray into SF in the middle section, I slowed down considerably while reading “An Orison of Sonmi 451”and “Sloosha’s Corossin’ an’ Ev’thin’ After.” The former was a dystopian story of the near future, which has precedents with Huxley and Orwell. It’s been done, and it’s been done better. I see Mitchell trying to channel Gibson here, or at least I guess that’s his influence. I must give him credit for setting it in Korea instead of Japan, despite his having lived here for a long time-but that would have been too cliché. The later is a sort of post-apocalyptic survival farce. To be honest, my interest was really flagging here, which is too bad, because I really enjoyed the first two sections.
http://patrickmccoy.typepad.com/lost_in_translation/books/page/40/
NUMBR9DREAM in my mind is homage to Murakami. It is an excellent mimicry, but it also includes the elements that I find tiresome and trite-the fantasy and SF sections. (I guess those just aren’t my cup of tea), here are my critiques of this book from 2003 followed by the blog link:
There are elements of fantasy and science fiction, however, I can't see how they move the story along or add to it. I find it something that I usually overlooked in Murakami's work, because of all the other great qualities his novels possess. Early in the novel, the main character Eiji has several sci-fi fantasy sequences that d little other than introduce some characters and make you wonder what kind of book you've gotten yourself into. Later, there is a sequence where Eiji is hiding out reading fantastical stories by the occupant of the safe house, which almost seems like filler, and to be honest I skimmed most of those stories. And instead of naming his novel after a Beatles song like Murakami, "Norwegian Wood", he has named it after a John Lennon song, "number9dream."
Furthermore, I had trouble getting around the English slang. I know he was making an approximation of how Japanese in meaning and tone would sound in English. And he has had success with an idea that I've had as well, which is to write a typical literary story, but set it in Japan in order to distinguish it from the hundreds of other literary novels. And to Mitchell’s credit, he has had a lot of success in doing so.
http://patrickmccoy.typepad.com/lost_in_translation/2003/08/number9dream.html
My first paid piece of journalism was a review of GHOSTWRITTEN for The Daily Mainichi News in 1999 or 2000 (I don’t have a clipping!). I basically said that he had enormous talent and produced a very ambitious first novel, but was too derivative in his plots (heist capers and end of the world scenarios) and styles (Murakami and Hornby).
So I’m happy to see how far he has come over the years. I feel kinship with him as he started out in Japan and made it big. Maybe someday I will write that novel kicking around in my head.
Recent Comments