These two films, This Is England, and The History Boys both take place in England in the 80s and follows a groups of boys as they grow up into an unstable society. However, these films depict two very different ways of life and show how race, class, and sexual orientation affect the core of most people’s experience.
This Is England is a semiautobiographical story of director Sean Meadows who grew up too fast as a skinhead. His alter ego is Shaun, a lonely boy whose father died in the Falkland War. He falls in with a group of friendly skinheads. Things change when Combo arrives on the scene after being released from jail and brings his white power National Front ideology into the group and splits it up. It is a disturbing look at what the lower class subgroups that feel disposed and powerless will do in order to create a sense of purpose and power through hate. The fact that Shaun is truly 12 years old is impressive, but I find it hard to see him as anything other than a mascot-he doesn’t seem to be precocious the way that I think a person would have to be in order to be accepted by those older in the teenage years. This sense of youth and nativity is stretched thin with credibility with the clearly decade or older Goth girlfriend of Shaun. I think this depiction of growing up too fast too young is an ailment of many societies where lack of money, education, and parental supervision prevail. It is a cautionary tale in the sense that it depicts how things can go horribly wrong when one feels the need to grow up too fast.
The History Boys shows a very different set of young men who have done extremely well academically on the national achievement tests, the A-Levels. There is another round of tests which will establish who gets into what schools they get into, so the school is trying to prepare them as best as they can so that it will give prestige to the school. The boys come from a variety of backgrounds (it is a private school-which is the British equivalent of an American public school), so they are all overachievers from lower to middle class backgrounds of different ethnicities. The film debates the merits of education for education’s sake as education as a means of financial success and future mobility, as seen in the different teaching and educational philosophies of Irwin, a young iconoclastic teacher trying to get the students to think out side the box and Hector, a traditionalist who is trying to impart a love of learning in the boys. However, there’s an undercurrent of homosexual relations love and relations between men and boys. I guess this inevitable since it is a boy’s school; and England has a long tradition of such behavior at these schools. Unlike the boys of This Is England they have bought into the status quo and will compete to gain entry into the world of money and status despite their backgrounds and class, rather than rebel against it and reveling in the outsider status. Incidently great soundtrack: New Order, The Smiths, etc...
Recent Comments