This week’s “U.S. Culture-lessons from the classroom” focuses on different perspectives on freedom. Kimiko Manes states that her students think that there is little freedom in Japan and she counters:
Ironically, as a Japanese living in the United States, I sometimes feel that there is not a lot of freedom here. For example, if I don't mow the lawn around the house, I will get a complaint. Even if I own my own home, I am not allowed to paint it a color that does not "blend in" with the neighborhood. If I remodel my house, not only will I get taxed depending on the number of bedrooms, I must first seek permission from the local authorities for even minor changes. Because of zoning laws, which strictly designate areas as residential, commercial and industrial, even if I wanted to open an innocuous hobby shop at my house, I cannot since I live in a residential area.
I think these are very superficial claims, and you encounter similar lack of freedoms in Japan. Most people have apartments and cannot make changes. Neighbors complain if you put out mixed garbage or park bicycles in the wrong area. Japan has a myriad of laws that prevent you from doing most things in a straightforward manner. No street shoes (shoes worn outdoors) are allowed in the gym. There are dress codes requiring students to wear them at schools and at some offices you have to wear uniforms as well. Students have to choose one activity for three years (in America you can change by season or year). You aren’t supposed to use garbage cans in meeting rooms (then why are they in there?). Many workers are expected to work unpaid overtime. Sometimes they are expected to go drinking with colleagues or clients even if they don’t want to. Lunches must be taken from 12 to 1. There are no sick days-you have to use holiday in most cases. The list goes on and on.
However, I have to concur with Manes when she says:
In an individualistic society, in order to prevent individual desires from infringing on the "common good," each area has strict regulations enforced by the local authorities. Japan is more of a group society, with a strong emphasis on trust, so rules have been followed with a high degree of compliance, and that has given Japan one of the lowest crime rates in the world.
In an individualistic society, in order to prevent individual desires from infringing on the "common good," each area has strict regulations enforced by the local authorities. Japan is more of a group society, with a strong emphasis on trust, so rules have been followed with a high degree of compliance, and that has given Japan one of the lowest crime rates in the world.
She goes on to talk about a former student who decided he liked a lot of things about Japanese society, but I don’t see these as examples of “freedoms”:
He also observed that the Japanese dress up when they leave their homes. Steve, who always wore sweatshirts when he was not working, started to think more about his clothing after six months in Japan.
I’ve had Japanese people tell me the exact opposite; that they felt freer to dress casual abroad than in Japan, where they were expected to keep up with their friends. Then she goes on to say:
In Japan, since public transit is efficient, one need not have a car. Most times, the employer will subsidize the commuting fares as well. Many companies have dormitories, and employees can live there relatively inexpensively. Also, there are extra funds that are given to employees who have dependent children. Frequently, the company owns a recreational facility in a resort area, and employees can take vacations there with their families. If there is an individual problem, frequently the employer or coworkers will help out. He felt that none of these things were true in the United States, and realized that he had come to prefer living in a society where there is more interaction, connection and shared communal responsibility than is true of the typical U.S. experience, centered as it is on the nuclear family as an extension of the individual. Recently, Steve put in a transfer request to move to his company's Tokyo subsidiary.
While, these things are true-are they freedoms? I think the point in which she states “more interaction, connection and shared communal responsibility” is oppressive paternalism. And as a foreigner I can live outside the system and there is less pressure to conform to community/social standards. If I were a Japanese national I imagine I would try to move away. When I visited NY, I talked to a Japanese national who had lived in NY for seven years he said the main reason he lived in the US was “freedom.”
Click here to read the whole article.
Recent Comments