Kimiko Manes looks at the differences in office/customer service behavior in the latest U.S. Culture-Lesson from the Classroom column in The Daily Yomiuri:
In the United States, the whole society is founded on the premise that individuals are given rights and responsibilities (although sometimes I think the "responsibilities" part has fallen by the wayside these days). If some work is given to an individual, he or she is responsible for completing it, and that responsibility must be respected: meddling with their work is a professional violation. Therefore, even if you work with someone in the same office, unless you are specifically asked for help, or directed by a supervisor to help, that individual is solely responsible for that work.
Of course, if there is a mistake, it is that individual's responsibility, and if the errors are too numerous or grave, one can get fired. Not helping coworkers, then, can be an act of respect for their work, and it is also a way to deflect responsibility in case their work turns out to be shoddy. This is the line between oneself and someone else's responsibility; anything that is out of an individual's jurisdiction, then, becomes "none of my business." This seems to be how an individualistic society works.
However, if you are given a task or agree to do a specific job, you are free to finish your work however you see fit. For example, a businessperson might be given a limit, say, "up to 1 million dollars" to complete a deal. If it is within that area, that person has the power to make decisions. How favorable the negotiated deal is might help that businessperson's career, but unlike Japan, he or she will not have to talk with the main office or "honsha."
I agree that this happens to an extent, but I think that if something needs to be taken care of-it often is. Whereas their Japnese counterparts are paralyzed if something is out of order-there are no exceptions and rules must be followed to the letter:
On the other hand, according to one American who resided in Japan for a long time, "When a foreigner goes to city hall or a bank in Japan, workers at the windows are extremely polite but they have to consult with other coworkers or supervisors before they can process the paperwork or transaction. Because the individual isn't given any sort of responsibility, they have to consult each other to make decisions."
He's absolutely correct. Unless it pertains to something very specific, individuals cannot make decisions easily in the Japanese workplace. Work tends to be done by groups in Japan, and everyone can do each other's work. To facilitate this, routines are set up. To oblige the foreigner who visits the city office, city workers might have to ask their coworkers and their supervisors if the routine set up for Japanese people will be appropriate for the foreigner.
Unlike the United States, most people in an office can help that person, but the placement of responsibility is unclear. Therefore, the Japanese tend not to favor changing routines, and sometimes even think that the routines cannot be changed.
People unconsciously form a paradigm to view the world around them, and they tend to prefer the system with which they are most familiar. It has taken me a long time to understand American society, and I think that there are many Japanese in the United States who never seem to understand how things "work." Similarly, I assume that some foreigners in Japan also take time to understand and accept how things are carried out in Japan.
Beauracracy here is in a class by itself. I need to get a $5 money order fro my correspondance course. I had to fill out a form in triplicate and had to write my address three times, the address of the receiver twice and disclose what it was for whcih I wrote "school fees" in English since I didn't have my Japanse dictionary with me. They called me no less than three times to find out what the $5 was for-WTF?
Another time I needed to renew my VISA two week before returning to the U.S. when it would expire while I was gone, and I told the clerk Ihad a special case and neede to get this done quickly-he claimed that had had no power and that it was up to the main branch in Otemachi. I got it but with no help from the clerk, I find people reluctant to take responsibililty for promises here in order to save their butts in many cases.
I guess I've accepted the Japanese system-it's not goingto change anytime soon, and I realize neither is perfect.
Recent Comments